Why is my landing page not converting? 4 checks first

Before you redesign, run four checks in order: a clear message, one button, a small first step and a page that matches the ad.

A business owner looking worried at a landing page on his laptop.
On this page 4 min read
  1. 01Can a stranger tell what you do in five seconds?
  2. 02Is there one obvious button?
  3. 03How much does your first step ask for?
  4. 04Does the page match the ad or link that brought people there?
  5. 05What does a small first step look like in practice?
  6. 06When is a redesign the right call?

Key takeaways

  1. [object Object]
  2. [object Object]
  3. [object Object]
  4. [object Object]
  5. [object Object]
  6. [object Object]

People land on your page and leave. Nobody signs up, nobody books a call. The first thought is usually "the design must be bad, I need a new one".

Maybe. But a redesign is the slowest and most expensive fix, so check four cheaper things first, in this order. Is the message clear in five seconds? Is there one obvious button? How much does the first step ask for? Does the page match the ad or link that brought people there? Each one only matters once the one before it passes.

Can a stranger tell what you do in five seconds?

Short answer: If not, fix the headline before you touch anything else.

This is the five-second test. Show your page to someone who doesn't know your business. Count to five and hide the screen. Then ask two questions: what does this company sell, and who is it for?

If they can't answer, the page is unclear. That's a different problem from ugly, and a new color palette won't fix it.

  • Before: "The future of smarter workflows."
  • After: "Scheduling software for dental clinics. Patients book online, your front desk stops answering the phone."

The first headline could be about anything. The second tells you the product, the customer and the result. I go deeper on this in the post on what a landing page needs above the fold.

Ask a friend outside your industry, not a colleague. Colleagues already know what you do, so they fill the gaps without noticing. A stranger can't, and that's the point.

Is there one obvious button?

Short answer: Pick one action for the page and make its button the loudest thing on the screen.

A lot of pages ask for four things at once: Start free trial, Book a demo, Watch the video, Join the newsletter. All four in the same size and color. When every button shouts, people don't pick one. They scroll, and then they leave.

  • Before: four buttons in the hero, all filled, all the same color.
  • After: one filled button that says "Start free trial", and one quiet text link under it for "Watch a 2-minute demo".

A quick check: squint at your page until the text blurs. If you can't tell which button is the main one, your visitors can't either. This is visual hierarchy, the first of the 5 Laws of UX I check on any page.

Also look at the label. "Submit" and "Learn more" don't say what happens next. "Get my free quote" does. There's more on this in the post on the best text for a call to action button.

How much does your first step ask for?

Short answer: Ask only for what you need to start. Collect the rest later.

Someone clicked your button. That's a small yes. Now look at what you ask for in return. If the next screen wants a phone number, a company size, a job title and a budget before they've seen anything, the trade is no longer worth it to them.

  • Before: a 9-field signup form: full name, work email, phone, company, job title, company size, country, password, how did you hear about us.
  • After: 3 fields: name, email, password. The rest is asked inside the product, when there's a reason for it.

Go through each field and ask: do I use this answer in the first five minutes? If not, it can wait.

Short answer: The headline should repeat the promise people clicked on.

People arrive with a sentence already in their head. It's the ad, the search result or the post they clicked. If your page opens with a different sentence, they think they're in the wrong place and go back.

  • Before: the ad says "Free invoice templates for freelancers". The page headline says "The all-in-one finance platform for modern teams".
  • After: the ad says "Free invoice templates for freelancers". The page headline says "Free invoice templates for freelancers. Pick one and send it today."

If you run several ads with different promises, one page can't match them all. Make a version of the page for each promise. Often only the headline and the first image need to change.

What does a small first step look like in practice?

Short answer: Let people get the value before you ask them for anything.

Say you run a bookkeeping service and your page offers a free tax checklist. One version asks for name, email, phone, company size and annual revenue before the download starts. Another shows the first page of the checklist right there, then asks for an email to send the full file.

The second one asks for less, and it asks after the visitor has seen that the checklist is worth having. That's the idea behind check three.

The same works for software. Let people try a demo or a sample project without an account. If there's a free plan, don't ask for a card to start it. Every wall you put before the value is a place where people turn back.

When you do need details, ask at the moment they make sense. A shipping address belongs in checkout, not in signup. A team size belongs in the step where people invite their team.

When is a redesign the right call?

Short answer: When all four checks pass and the page still looks untrustworthy or breaks on a phone.

Sometimes the design is the problem. Text too small to read on mobile, a layout that falls apart on narrow screens, or a look so dated that people doubt the business is still running. Those are real reasons.

But run the four checks first. If the headline is vague, a new design will just be a nicer-looking page with a vague headline. And if you do end up redesigning, you'll hand your designer a clear message, one action and a short form. That gives the redesign a much better starting point.

If you've run the four checks and aren't sure what you're looking at, book a call. Send me the page and I'll tell you what I'd fix first. I reply within a day.

Questions

  • Looks and clarity are separate things. A good-looking page can still hide what you sell, split attention across too many buttons, ask for too much up front or break the promise of the ad. Check those four first.

  • Show the page to someone who doesn't know your business for five seconds, then hide it. Ask what the company sells and who it's for. If they can't say, rewrite the headline.

  • As few as you need to get someone started. For most products that's an email and a password, sometimes a name. Ask for everything else once they're inside.

Share this article

Have a project in mind?

Book a short call. We'll talk through what you're building, and I'll tell you how I can help.

Length
15 minutes
Where
Cal Video
Time zone
Metro Manila

Book a discovery call

Pick a time that suits you

The calendar runs on Cal.com, which sets its own cookies. Allow them to load it here, or email me and I’ll reply within a day.

Email me