Why does my AI app look generic? 5 fixes that work

AI tools reuse the same defaults, so sites look alike. Here are the tells that give yours away and five small fixes that make it yours.

A designer looking at an app on her laptop, with a notebook of hand-drawn design ideas beside it.
On this page 5 min read
  1. 01Why does my AI-built site look like everyone else's?
  2. 02How can you tell a site was vibe coded?
  3. 03What should I fix first?
  4. 04Do I really need just one accent colour?
  5. 05Which font and icons should I pick?
  6. 06How do I make the copy sound like my business?

Key takeaways

  1. [object Object]
  2. [object Object]
  3. [object Object]
  4. [object Object]
  5. [object Object]
  6. [object Object]

You built your site with an AI tool over a weekend. It works. But something about it feels off, and you can't say what. Your visitors can't say it either. They only know it looks like a lot of other sites they opened this month.

The reason is simple. AI tools reuse the same defaults, so sites start to look alike. Adrian Krebs scored 1,590 Show HN pages against 16 AI design patterns, and 22% of them triggered four or more (his design-slop study). You can fix it with five small decisions: a written design file, one accent colour, a deliberate font, real copy and one icon set.

Why does my AI-built site look like everyone else's?

Short answer: The tool fills every gap you leave with its safest default, and everyone gets the same defaults.

When you type "build me a landing page for my booking app", you haven't said which colour, which font, how much spacing or what tone. The tool has to pick something. It picks what it has seen most. The next founder types a similar prompt and gets the same picks.

The tool can follow design rules well. It only needs to be given some.

  • Before: "Build a landing page for my booking app."
  • After: "Build a landing page for my booking app. Follow the rules in my design file: one accent colour, this font, no gradients, icons from one set."

The second prompt takes ten more seconds to write. The result looks like it belongs to someone.

How can you tell a site was vibe coded?

Short answer: Look for the same handful of defaults stacked on one page. One on its own is fine. Four or more is the pattern.

These are on Krebs's list of patterns:

  • Inter in a centered hero. Fix: pick a font on purpose (more on that below).
  • Purple as the main colour. Fix: choose one accent that means something for your product.
  • Gradients on backgrounds, buttons and text. Fix: use flat colour. Keep a gradient only if you can say why it's there.
  • A small badge above the headline. Fix: delete it. Let the headline be the first thing people read.
  • Identical feature cards with an icon on top. Fix: show one feature with a real screenshot.
  • Emoji used as icons in the menu or sidebar. Fix: use a real icon set.
  • Untouched shadcn components. Fix: change the corner radius, the spacing and the colours so they match your rules.

And three more I look for myself. These are my own additions, not from the study:

  • Copy that could sit on any site. "Build faster. Scale smarter." Fix: say what the product does.
  • Emoji sprinkled through headings and bullet points. Fix: remove them and let the words carry it.
  • Icons from two or three different sets. Fix: one family, one weight.

What should I fix first?

Short answer: Write the design file first, because every other fix lives inside it.

A design file is a plain text file in your project that the AI tool reads before it builds anything. Most AI coding tools can load a rules file at the start of every session. It doesn't need to be long. A good one covers:

  • The one accent colour and where it's allowed to appear
  • The font, and the sizes for headings and body text
  • The spacing steps, so gaps stay consistent
  • How a button looks
  • Which icon set to use, and at which weight
  • Words and patterns to avoid, like gradients or a badge above the headline

Then fix things in this order: write the design file, cut down to one accent colour, choose the font, rewrite the copy, and swap the icons for one set.

Without the file, you fix the purple today and it comes back the next time you ask for a new page. For more on setting rules and checking AI output against them, see how to build with AI without losing quality.

Do I really need just one accent colour?

Short answer: For most small sites, yes. One accent shows people where to click.

If five things on the page are bright, nothing stands out. If only the main button is, the eye goes straight to it.

Say you run a made-up invoicing app. You pick green, because green reads as money and the app is about getting paid. Green goes on the main button, the active tab and the "paid" status. Everything else is neutral text on a neutral background. That is the whole rule. It's short enough for a tool to follow and short enough for you to check on every screen.

  • Before: purple buttons, a blue link, a pink gradient headline and a green success badge on one screen.
  • After: neutral text and backgrounds, and one colour that only shows up on the thing you want clicked.

Check the accent against your background for contrast too. A pale accent on white might look calm and still be hard to read.

Which font and icons should I pick?

Short answer: Any font you chose on purpose, and one icon family in one weight.

A common move is to swap Inter for whichever font is popular this month and call it done. It doesn't help much. Krebs's list flags trendy picks like Space Grotesk, Instrument Serif and Geist too. If the tool picked it for you, or you picked it because everyone else did, it's still a default. The name of the font matters less than the reason you chose it.

Pick for your brand's voice. A law firm and a kids' app shouldn't sound the same, and they shouldn't be set in the same type either. Write the choice into your design file so the tool stops reaching for its default.

Icons work the same way. Mixed sets are easy to spot because the line thickness and corner shapes change from one icon to the next. Pick any single, well-made set and stick to one weight. What matters is that every icon comes from the same family.

How do I make the copy sound like my business?

Short answer: Replace every line that could be pasted onto a competitor's site.

Read your headline and ask if another company could use it word for word. If yes, it's a placeholder, even if it sounds polished.

  • Before: "Build faster. Scale smarter."
  • After: "Book a dentist appointment without calling the clinic."

The second one names the customer, the task and the annoying part it removes. A tool can't write that for you without being told, because it comes from knowing your customers. The same goes for the first screen as a whole. See what to put in a landing page hero section for the rest of it.

If your site works but looks like everyone else's, book a call and send me the link. I'll tell you which of these to fix first. I reply within a day.

Questions

  • No. The trouble starts when nobody makes the design decisions, so the tool makes them for you.

  • Yes, for the basics. Write a short design file, cut down to one accent colour, pick a font on purpose, rewrite the copy and use one icon set. A designer helps when you're unsure what the rules should be.

  • No. The font is one of several defaults. If the purple gradient, the badge and the three icon cards stay, the page still reads as a template.

Share this article

Have a project in mind?

Book a short call. We'll talk through what you're building, and I'll tell you how I can help.

Length
15 minutes
Where
Cal Video
Time zone
Metro Manila

Book a discovery call

Pick a time that suits you

The calendar runs on Cal.com, which sets its own cookies. Allow them to load it here, or email me and I’ll reply within a day.

Email me