How many pricing tiers should a SaaS have? Fewer

How many pricing tiers should a SaaS have? Fewer than you think. When two plans are enough, when three make sense, and when to add one.

A founder with his hand on his chin, deciding between pricing plans on his laptop.
On this page 5 min read
  1. 01How many pricing tiers should a small SaaS have?
  2. 02Why do fewer plans make the decision faster?
  3. 03When are two plans enough?
  4. 04When does a third plan earn its place?
  5. 05Should I mark one plan as recommended?
  6. 06What should the plans be called and how should I show them?

Key takeaways

  1. [object Object]
  2. [object Object]
  3. [object Object]
  4. [object Object]
  5. [object Object]
  6. [object Object]

You're building a pricing page and it keeps growing. There's a Starter plan, a Pro plan, a Team plan, and an Enterprise column with a "Contact us" button because every other SaaS seems to have one. Now you have four columns, a table with twenty rows, and you can't tell which plan you would pick yourself.

Here's the short version. Fewer plans are clearer. Three plans with one marked as recommended is a good ceiling, and it's also the most common setup: close to half of the companies in ChartMogul's analysis of over 600 pricing pages offer three tiers. A small tool with one kind of customer can do fine with two.

How many pricing tiers should a small SaaS have?

Short answer: Two or three. Pick the smallest number that covers the customers you have today.

I think of every plan as a question you ask the visitor: "Are you this kind of customer?" One plan, one question. Four plans, four questions, and the visitor has to answer all of them before they can press a button.

If you sell to one kind of customer, you need one paid plan. Add a free one if people need to try the product before they trust it. That's two.

Three makes sense when you have clearly different groups. A solo user, a small team and a company do not need the same things, so each gets a column.

Here's a before and after.

Before: four plans called Starter, Plus, Pro and Business. The only difference is a limit: 5 projects, 15 projects, 50 projects, unlimited. To choose, the visitor has to guess how many projects they'll have next year.

After: two plans. Free does the core job. Pro adds the things you want once the work gets serious. The visitor answers one question: "Do I need those extras yet?"

Why do fewer plans make the decision faster?

Short answer: Every plan you add means more comparisons for the visitor, and the number grows faster than the columns do.

With two plans there is one comparison: this one or that one. With three plans there are three pairs to compare. With four there are six. You doubled the columns and got six times the comparisons.

This is choice overload, one of the 5 Laws of UX. When people face too many choices, they often pick none.

On a pricing page, picking none looks like this. The visitor doesn't choose the wrong plan. They close the tab to "think about it".

So the goal of the page is a fast, confident choice. Cutting a column is the cheapest way I know to get there.

When are two plans enough?

Short answer: When you have one kind of customer, and one kind of customer needs one paid plan.

Say you sell a scheduling tool for solo hair stylists. Every customer is one person with one chair. They all need the same thing: a booking page and reminders.

Two plans cover that:

  • Free: a booking page and up to a set number of bookings a month. Enough to see if it works.
  • Pro: a flat monthly price. It adds unlimited bookings, text reminders and your own logo on the page.

Free does the core job. Pro is for when the business is busy enough to need more. There is one comparison to make, and the visitor can make it in a few seconds.

The same thinking applies to the product itself. A tool for one kind of customer usually does fewer things well. A short feature list makes a short pricing page.

When does a third plan earn its place?

Short answer: When a real group of customers needs something different. More of the same thing is only a limit, and a limit can live inside a plan you already have.

Good reasons to add a plan:

  • A group keeps asking for something the others don't need, like several people sharing one account.
  • The buyer is different. A manager paying for five people decides differently from a freelancer paying for one.
  • That group costs you more to serve, so the price has to change with it.

Weak reasons to add a plan:

  • Your competitor has three.
  • The page looks empty with two columns.
  • You want a plan nobody is meant to buy, so the middle one looks cheap. Everyone still has to read that column.

In the stylist example, a Team plan would earn its place the day salons with five chairs start asking for one shared calendar. Until then, it's a column nobody needs.

Short answer: Yes when you have three. With two, the layout usually does it for you.

With three plans, pick the one that fits most of your customers and make it stand out. Give it a border, a "Recommended" label and the only filled button. The other two get outlined buttons. Now the visitor has a default, and they only read the other columns if the default feels wrong.

Only use a label like "Most popular" if it's true.

With two plans you don't need a badge. Decide which action you want more, and give that plan the filled button. If you want signups first, make Free the loud one. If you want paid users, make Pro the loud one.

What should the plans be called and how should I show them?

Short answer: Plain names, a visible price, and only the differences.

Call the plans what they are. Free, Pro and Team are clearer than Spark, Boost and Orbit. Nobody should have to learn your vocabulary to see the price.

Show the price as a number. If you have monthly and yearly billing, show both, like "$12 a month or $120 a year".

Then list only what changes between plans.

Before: two columns with 14 rows of checkmarks each. Eleven of the rows are the same in both.

After: Free lists what you get. Pro says "Everything in Free, plus" and then three lines.

The second version is shorter, and the visitor can see what the money buys without playing spot the difference.

If your pricing page has grown a column too many, book a call and send me the link to your current page. I'll help you cut it down to one clear choice. I reply within a day.

Questions

  • No. If you have one kind of customer, two plans cover it, one to try and one to pay for. Add a third when a real group asks for something the others don't need.

  • Not always. A free plan suits a tool that people want to try before they trust it, and that costs you little per user. If each user costs you real money or support time, a free trial may fit better.

  • Only if the price really depends on a conversation. If you have no enterprise customers yet, leave the column off and add it when the first one shows up.

Share this article

Have a project in mind?

Book a short call. We'll talk through what you're building, and I'll tell you how I can help.

Length
15 minutes
Where
Cal Video
Time zone
Metro Manila

Book a discovery call

Pick a time that suits you

The calendar runs on Cal.com, which sets its own cookies. Allow them to load it here, or email me and I’ll reply within a day.

Email me